Thursday, November 5, 2009

Homework 20- Big Paper

Introduction
Digitization is a huge part of today's world. Our society consists of using technology for everything we do and as humans strive for a better and faster world. Practically every teenager in today's world has some sort of an electronic device, whether it is an ipod, cell phone, camera, or other sorts of electronic devices. Although most people think that digital representation devices are corrupting the minds of our society’s youth, digital representation devices actually provide our society with the ability to keep in touch with everyone, and entertain and stimulate our minds through television and video game systems.

Arguement One
Technology provides our society with a faster way to keep in touch with people. Instead of sending letters, we can send emails that would reach the recipient faster, and text people when we feeling like having a quick chat. Websites such as Facebook or Myspace help us reconnect with old friends, or people in other countries. Through a satellite we can talk to people in China, Australia, or Russia, with the simple click of a mouse. Devices such as cell phones "make it easy to make business arrangements when you are traveling away from your office and can't call everyone by emailing or texting business associates." (http://www.ehow.com/facts_4812563_positive-effects-cell-phones.html). In this way, we are always connected if we choose to be. Several positive impacts of cell phones are "you can use it for emergency problems. Your cell phone can be a life saver. That’s why it is necessary to have a phone. You can never know when you will have a problem or you will be the witness of a car accident and you will have to call for an ambulance or Police. There are 160 000 wireless emergencies calls, which are made every day. This means 110 calls per minute." or "Because of all the things we see at news, parents buy cell phones for their children so they can know where they are all the time. This is another positive effect of cell phones. Parents don’t worry as much as they did before. With the help of the cell phones they now know where their children are, all the time." (http://www.w-cellphones.com/positive-effects-of-cell-phones/) By being always connected, people never feel like they are left out of the loop. With internet on our laptops and cell phones, we can always know what is going in on the world, and can always talk to people.

Arguement Two
Video games help stimulate our minds while improving our hand eye coordination and character survival skills. Video game systems such as the Wii also keep our bodies fit and in motion. Not all games make the players sit on their couches and stare at a TV screen; they also incorporate the movement of the player’s bodies. Video games do create a challenge for our brains. Even though we are not learning on an intellectual level, and are not using one of the academic subjects to complete our challenges, we are still improving our skills. We improve our hand-eye coordination, which is an important skill not taught in school, and we also learn how to better our characters in the games so that we do not get injured or die as often as we would in the beginning of the game. Steven Johnson, the author of "Everything Bad is Good For You”, wants readers to realize that there are benefits to our digital devices. In a way he is playing devil’s advocate to ever person who has the same generic response, “television and video games corrupt young children’s and teenager’s minds.” However, Johnson argues that video games actually stimulate our brain, because we make challenges for ourselves without even realizing it. In a video game, you must complete a level before you can reach the next one. As each level goes on, the challenges become harder and harder, and that is when skill levels come in. To many people, you just need to know how to shoot a gun or kill an enemy, but when analyzed further, one realizes that there is skill behind these techniques. Also, by trying to get onto the next level, a self designed goal in created in the player’s mind. They have a target they need to reach, and have the urge to succeed. In a conversation I had with Carrie Li, I asked her how she thought the Wii stimulated our body motions. The conversation is pasted below:
Me: how do you think wii's stimulate our mind and bodies in physical motions?
Carrie: it makes us interact physically with the game rather than the typical video games, where u only have a control and you're only moving your fingers
Me: do you think it stimulates our brain also?
Carrie:so i guess it links your mind with your physical activities
like how you would in real life
Me: do you think it stimulates our brain also?
Carrie: yeah
Carrie proved my point that video games do help stimulate our mind and body. It keeps our body fit, and keeps our mind entertained. Although not every video game keeps us physically fit, one cannot say that there is not a system that doesn’t.

Arguement Three
Television stimulates our mind, even though our body is at rest. While some people think that we are just mindless bodies watching a box with images, some shows actually make us think, and analyze what is going on. In "Everything Bad is Good for you”, Steven Johnson argues that television also stimulates the mind. While some people think that we are just mindless bodies watching a box with images, Johnson argues that some shows make us think, and analyze what is going on. Shows such as ER, House, Lost, and Flash Forward, make the viewers analyze what is happening, and in the case of Lost and Flash Forward, predict an outcome. In the case of ER and House, viewers are able to actually see what goes on in a medical room, an experience they would not likely have in their daily lives. All though they are not actually in the hospital, they can imagine themselves as if they are. Below are some of television’s positive sides, pulled from http://www.odec.ca/projects/2005/zerb5m0/public_html/positiveEf.html
• helps people to learn about other cultures
• gives family members of all ages an opportunity to spend time together while watching it
• parents can use TV to get kids reading by getting books on the same subjects
• parents and children can talk about TV programs
• educational programs can teach children new things, and even help them make new friends
• news, current events and historical programs can help kids find out more about other cultures and people
• documentaries can create a picture of the world in kids' minds
• cultural programs can show children the world of music and art
Along with stimulating our minds, television also helps people learn, especially children. Children are able to watch educational shows that teach them the alphabet, or how to spell. Programs such as PBS Thirteen specialize in a child’s learning.

Arguement Four
Technology also plays a huge part in our advancement of science. Every day, scientists are constantly trying to come up with cures for Cancer, or other diseases. Just recently, scientists came out with a Swine Flu shot. They would not have been able to come out with this shot without the efficient use of technology. With our advances in machines and computers, scientists can quickly diagnose a patient and create a medicine or prescribe a medicine that can keep them healthy or make them feel better. In the 1340’s, the Black Plague was a deathly disease that swept through Europe and killed millions of civilians. “By the time the epidemic played itself out three years later, anywhere between 25% and 50% of Europe's population had fallen victim to the pestilence.” If, God Forbid, we were to have something like the Black Plague sweep our nation, our scientists would have the technology to either stop or cure this disease. Back in the 1340’s, scientists did not have the technology to come up with a cure for this disease, but now with our technological advancements, a cure might be possible.

Opposing Viewpoints
Books such as Feed by M.T Anderson contradict what I just said about the use digital devices and always being connected. In Feed, the characters have a permanent “Feed” attached to their brain, which keeps them connected at all times. Since Feed is an allegory of our world, Anderson is trying to say that the “Feed” in the character’s minds are like our cell phones, laptops, and other digital devices. With these devices, we are always connected, 24/7. In Feed, the characters cannot shut off the “Feed”, not like they would want to. Anderson argues that in our world, people are so attached to their digital devices that they would not be able to live without it if it was to be taken from them.

When M.T Anderson wrote the book Feed, he meant it to be an allegory of the modern day teenage life. He didn’t want readers to think that he was capturing what he thought would happen in the future, more he wanted readers to see what our world is like right now. I do believe that Feed is on target because it perfectly captures the life of a teenager in our current period of time. While reading this book, I realized that the Feeds in the character’s heads represented the technology we teenagers use. Even if we do not have a chip in our head generating information for us whenever we need it, we do have cell phones and computers that can retrieve information with the click of a button. In a way, we are always connected to technology, like the characters in Feed are. People might argue that we do not have our digital devices on us 24/7, which are true, but everywhere we go we are faced with a source of technology. Whether it is the cell phones in our pockets or the iPods attached to our ears, we are practically always connected in one way or another. Everywhere we turn, we see representations of technology, whether it be the huge televisions in Times Square or the moving advertisements on television screens on our local city buses or taxis. We can’t escape from this technological oppression, even in our own homes. However, this technological oppression also helps us learn about our world, and entertain our minds. If we wanted, we could turn off our digital devices and do something else with our day.

Comparison of Two Books
Johnson and M.T Anderson have two completely different views in their books. In Feed, Anderson was all about how technology is bad for us, and how it is corrupting our minds. He went on to explain that our world is consumed with technology, and that we are hit with it 24/7. However, Johnson is claiming that television and video games are good for us, and that it is not corrupting us. Although I believe that the two authors contradicted each other, I also believe that they were talking about two different aspects of digitalization. In Feed, Anderson was talking more about a “Feed” representing a cell phone or laptop in our world, and how we are always connected, every minute of the day. Like the Feed, most people will not turn off their cell phone or laptop, and find that they cannot live without it. Johnson is talking more about television and video games, and how they stimulate our minds and make us set up personal challenges for ourselves. Anderson does not touch on televisions and video games too much, as it is not his main focus. He wants people to see the fact that we are always connected. Johnson did not focus on cell phone or laptop use, rather the entertainment use of technology.

Opposing Viewpoints
On the contrary, being always connected in our society does limit our ability to keep our privacy. When sending a text message or an email, anyone can retrieve it, because what goes into cyberspace stays in cyberspace. The internet and cell phones do limit our privacy, and many people complain about privacy invasion. Business people call their Blackberry’s “Crackberry’s” because of their addictiveness. Imagine that instead of being on “Crack”, your blackberry was a drug. By having a Blackberry on you 24/7, your boss can constantly call you or email you to keep in touch with you, even if you are on vacation. However, if people did want to step away from our technologically-obsessed society, they could shut off their electronic devices and spend time outdoors with people they love. Most people do not do this people they are addicted, but it’s not like we don’t have the ability to shut the devices off.

Connections
This paper connects to our current-day society because it is about our current-day society. In a world filled with technology, this paper focuses on the pros of our technological use.

Significance
The significance of this paper is for people to understand that technology has pros in our society. People are always claiming technology is so bad, and it corrupts our mind, but my point in this paper was to show the benefits of living in a world filled with technology. Without our technology, science would not be half as advanced as it is today, we would not be able to talk to people around the world, or know what is happening in other countries. We would not be able to stay in touch with people with the click of a button or the ring of a cell phone. Technology has its pros, but people are always forgetting about them.

Conclusion
In conclusion, technology is a huge-step forward in our society, and without it we would be nowhere. Technology helps advance science, and always keeps us connected. It also keeps our minds and bodies stimulated, even if it through the simple use of a television or video game. Although most people think that digital representation devices are corrupting the minds of our society’s youth, digital representation devices actually provide our society with the ability to keep in touch with everyone, and entertain and stimulate our minds through television and video game systems.

Works Cited Page:
Anderson, M.T. Feed. Somerville, MA: Candlewick Press, 2002. Print.
Johnson, Steven. Everything Bad Is Good for You . Print.

Zerbes, Maryam. "Postive Effects of TV." How Much TV Should Kids Watch? Web. 8 Nov. 2009. .

"Positive Effects of Cell Phones." eHow. eHow, Web. 8 Nov. 2009. .

"Positive effects of cell phones ." Cell Phones. Web. 8 Nov. 2009. .

"The Black Death, 1348," EyeWitness to History, www.eyewitnesstohistory.com (2001).

3 comments:

  1. Rachel,

    I like what you have so far, Your paper has everything that it needs to have. There are some things that you can make stronger though.

    If I were to be grading your paper at this moment I would give you a total of 22/28. For your point of view I gave you 3 points. I feel like what you have is interesting and well said but it doesn't seem to be "sharp". For the evidence I gave you 3 points; you cite many sources and explain what you found. I think that you should get more accurate evidence. For example in your first paragraph you talk about cell phones and how they help us connect with each other. You use a quote about how it helps business people but that just limits the people who actually have a career in business. If I were you I would find a quote about how someone used their cell phone when they were in need of help. That is something that seems to relate to everyone. For organization I would give you 3 points. The overall structure of the paper is very good. I feel like your thesis needs to be short and simple. Remember your thesis is what you are trying to prove in your paper. You want the reader to have that in mind the whole time they are reading your paper. If you keep it short and simple they will remember the main point of your paper better. For connections and significance I would give you a total of 4 points. I feel like you do a great job making comparisons between the two authors. Opposing view points I would give 3 points. You don't seem to use any quotes or any other type of evidence though. Written communication would be a 3 as well. I feel like if you read your paper aloud to your self then you would be able to catch many mistakes. Same goes for communication performance.

    Great job so far though, I have not completed my revised draft so I was able to learn many new things while reading and grading yours.

    Later,
    Amber

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Rachel,

    Nice thesis. I like how you chose to support digitalization instead of going against it like everyone else is or at least all the ones I've read so far.

    "By being always connected, people never feel like they are left out of the loop." It's true that with pictures and gossip spreading like wildfire all over the net that others lives become part of ours. But do you think that because of this our society has become too fast paced and it's harder to keep our lives private? (opposing argument maybe?)

    "Technology has its pros, but people are always forgetting about them." It's true. We are always outweighing the cons over the pros. We have to look at it in the long term. It all depends on us whether we use it "correctly" or not. I think you should add on some more opposing viewpoints though to make your arguments stronger because I know there are a lot of arguments that oppose the use of technology.

    I like your use of quotes although I have to say my quote was a bit typical. Maybe analyze the wii more after our conversation. I think you should take your idea to the next level and propose other good aspects of it other than the ones Johnson pointed out. Expand more on your science idea, that science advancements are crucial to understanding our world better and isn't that what life is about? Understanding our world better?

    Anyway I don't have much criticism. Your essay's looking really good so far. Looking forward to see the end result.

    (Oh also revise your citations. You don't want anything like that bringing your grade down.)

    ReplyDelete